From: Linda (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Fri Jul 21 2000 - 21:21:13 PDT
This company is in trouble - it's stock price is now just under 14,
the all-time-high being 243 in February. A quick look at this
quarter's earnings release reveals net revenue of 1.8M, cash burn
of 33M over the quarter, lots of long term debt ...
Ventro's Numbers Just Don't Add Up
By Joe Bousquin
7/21/00 12:02 AM ET
Don't be fooled by the $25.2 million in "total" revenue
that B2B electronic marketplace Ventro (VNTR:Nasdaq -news)
reported for the second quarter on Thursday. While the
headline number seems impressive, it doesn't compare to
the revenue reported by sector leaders Ariba (ARBA:Nasdaq - news),
Commerce One (CMRC:Nadaq - news) and PurchasePro.com
(PPRO:Nasdaq - news).
While the company's 74-cent per-share loss was six cents better
than the 80-cent consensus loss forecast by First Call/Thomson
Financial, it missed on the crucial transaction fees
analysts were eyeing. That performance calls into question how
quickly B2B transactions, hailed as the frictionless way to do
business just months ago, will grow at the thousands of marketplaces
cropping up in industries from construction to cattle.
"The company clearly has stumbled pretty badly," says Ian Toll,
an analyst with Credit Suisse First Boston." The market is likely
to see this as a major setback."
Toll, whose company hasn't done underwriting for Ventro, was
preparing to downgrade the company from buy to market perform.
He wasn't alone; two other analysts contacted by TSC were getting
ready to cut Ventro as well.
In after-hours trading, the stock fell 2 3/8, or 12%, to 18.
Ventro's $25.2 million total revenue figure is tied to the value
of goods that passed through the exchange. The amount the Mountain
View, Calif.-based company actually pocketed in the form of net
revenue: $1.8 million. No wonder the 500-person company managed to lose
$33.1 million for the quarter.
Ventro's problems underscore slowing growth of transaction volume
over the company's network. The firm's $29.1 million in transactions
this quarter was 9% higher than the previous quarter. That
fell short of the $30 million mark analysts had expected and well
below the $35 million they had hoped for.
Ventro President and CEO David Perry concedes the figure fell below
expectations, but claims the industry is healthy.
"We would have expected [transaction volume] to be north of
$30 million and the fact that it wasn't could be construed
as disappointing," Perry said in an interview after the company's
conference call. But he said robust results at other B2B
companies bode well for his own.
Ariba recently reported revenue of $80 million; Commerce One,
$62 million; and PurchasePro.com, $9.5 million.
Ventro's $1.8 million in net revenue, by comparison, included
$1.2 million in transaction fees and $600,000 from services.
Because analysts were expecting $1.7 million from transactional fees
alone, the company actually missed transaction estimates by $500,000, or
"They hit the bottom line overall, which is what's most important,
but they didn't do it in the way we expected, and it makes it look like
the [exchange] portion of business is starting to flatten out,"
says Jon Ekoniak, an analyst at U.S. Bancorp Piper Jaffray. "I see it
like going to the prom with your sister. The great part is that you
got to go to the prom. The bad part is that you went with your sister."
Ekoniak has placed his buy rating on the stock under review. His firm
has not done underwriting for the company.
Ventro's Perry, however, sees the breakdown as a bullish development
for the company, which started trading a year ago.
"The fact that our lower transactional revenues were offset by a service
revenue stream that people didn't expect us to have should be seen as a
positive," Perry said. "Analysts ought to take another look -- we're
finding more and more ways to make money."
Perhaps. But regardless of the diversity of Ventro's revenue streams,
$1.8 million still ain't a lot of money in the B2B
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Fri Jul 21 2000 - 21:18:17 PDT