[FoRK] Re: A bit of religion - Problem of Evil

Lucas Gonze lgonze
Sun Jan 8 14:54:23 PST 2006



On Thu, 5 Jan 2006, Russell Turpin wrote:
> Lucas Gonze <lgonze at panix.com>:
>> That seems by far the most parsimonious explanation of the evidence.  The 
>> guy's biography is the central feature of the religion.
>
> Actually, no. The alleged biographies were
> written after the religion had been spread, its
> leadership established, practice laid down, and
> doctrinal letters circulated. Most of the New
> Testament was written prior to the gospels.
> Once you have enough people subscribing to
> a god or hero, he has to have a lifestory.
> When they were needed, they were written.
> But the religion came first.

The biography is the religion.  There's nothing else in it but 
explanations of the biography.  ...really, the only part that the founder 
had to play was the passion, all the rest followed from that.

The religion is about a singular act of human sacrifice to the god.  One 
final history-rewriting biographical event.  This is not something that 
could have been added after the fact; it had to have always been the main 
feature of the religion, even during the lifetime of the guy, even during 
the period before the idea of the sacrifice itself was consciously 
articulated.





More information about the FoRK mailing list