[FoRK] Re: Amazing

mattj at newsblip.com < mattj at newsblip.com > on > Tue Mar 14 09:02:13 PST 2006

> I also read a story like that, except that I think it was a rotating
> cylinder coated in wax. Or maybe it was tin foil; I forget.

Tinfoil first, at least according to Hollywood.


As I mentioned in old bits, I bought the hobby kit that makes an Edison 
cylinder recorder that records on plastic cups. (I still haven't 
assembled it yet, though.)

The cylinder recorder was replaced by the more space-efficient record 
discs, of course.  (Edison fought that, as he fought many improvements 
of his work.)  Anyway,  I was just wondering what the most 
space-efficient format would be for a groove recording. And in a 
practical sense; what shape of medium would allow the biggest 
collection (in recorded hours) to sit in someone's closet?

Rectangular shapes fill up rectangular closets fairly well.  But if the 
player is moving this rectangle in zigzags, like a CRT's electron beam, 
it seems a little tricky to swing the pickup needle around to the next 
groove.  Even if that problem is solved, it might be best to have a 
looooong rectangle, so you canmaximize the straightaways and minimize 
the hairpin turns, if just for easier maintenance.

Matt Jensen

More information about the FoRK mailing list