[FoRK] Kindle first impressions

Jeff Bone <jbone at place.org> on Sun May 4 11:52:34 PDT 2008

Short version:  aw hell, Bezos found a way to maximize the flow of  
money from me to him EVEN FURTHER.

General comments:
   - far better experience than Sony's e-reader, IMHO anyway
   - still not sold on the necessity of e-ink over LCD, but getting  
   - display is crisper, more stable, less murky than other e-ink  
   - little glitter progress thingie just as weird as it looks in  
   - holding one-handed w/o accidentally turning pages takes work
   - next page button on the right a pain
   - keyboard a bit awkward
   - needs larger, centered space button on keyboard
   - cover they send fails to securely hold device
   - they need to do a deep integration w/ O'Reilly Safari
   - nav wheel / button / ribbon mechanism still a bit freaky
   - do you really need both Back and Prev Page buttons?
   - wish it had better note taking, browsing, PIM (sigh...)
   - store works great!
   - WhisperNet works great, great idea (killer feature?)

Major caveat:  obtained the free PDF of Russell Standish's excellent  
book Theory of Nothing and used Amazon service via e-mail to reformat  
and push the document to my device.  It made a mild hash of navigation  
and a complete hash of equations and any symbolic notation.  They  
still have work to do to make this usable for technical or math  

Long version:  read my first Kindle book yesterday afternoon and  
evening, Julian Dibbell's Play Monty.  (Purchased three:  Dibbell,  
Ariely's Predictably Irrational, and Harford's The Logic of Life.  Not  
sure why Dibbell got the nod for the first read, though;  whim, I  
suppose...)  I think I'm reading even faster on this thing than on  
paper, which surprises me.  Wonderful experience;  reading outside in  
daylight and dusk, inside while watching a movie with the lights low,  
in bed with bedside lamp.  Couldn't bring myself to risk ruining the  
device by taking in the bathtub --- not the first day, anyway.  But  
the overall experience was very seamless, very pleasant.

Like it.  Not TiVo love it.  Not Mac Air love it.  Not Syntax-Olevia  
love it.  Not Python love it.  Not del.icio.us love it.  Not hp15c  
love it.  Not even iPhone really, really like it.  But like it ---  
better than expected.  I can see this evolving into something really  
significant over time, assuming they keep their eye on the ball and  
keep trying out new ideas with the product line.


More information about the FoRK mailing list